Canadian Housing Market Stuck In A Holding Pattern

Following the Bank of Canada’s third interest rate cut of the year, national home sales increased slightly in September compared to August. This follows a similar pattern of gains recorded in the months following the first two rate cuts.

Home sales recorded over Canadian MLS® Systems climbed 1.9% month-over-month in September 2024, reaching their highest level since July 2023. The Greater Toronto Area, Hamilton-Burlington, Montreal and Quebec City, Greater Vancouver and Victoria led the national increase.

“Sales gains are now three for three in the months following interest rate cuts, which is a trend even though the increases weren’t headline-grabbing,” said Shaun Cathcart, CREA’s Senior Economist. “That said, with the pace of rate cuts now expected to be much faster than previously thought, it’s possible some buyers may choose to hold off on a purchase for now. This could further boost the rebound expected in 2025 at the expense of the last few months of this year”.

New Listings

New listings posted a 4.9% month-over-month rise in September, as sellers listed properties in more significant than normal numbers for the first weeks of the month. Gains were broad-based, with most of the country’s biggest markets topping the list.

At the end of September 2024, 185,427 properties were listed for sale on all Canadian MLS® Systems, up 16.8% from a year earlier but still below historical averages of around 200,000 listings for that time of the year.

With sales rising by less than new listings in September, the national sales-to-new listings ratio eased to 51.3%, down from 52.8% in August. This measure could be reversed if all those listings increase sales in October. The long-term average for the national sales-to-new listings ratio is 55%, with a sales-to-new listings ratio between 45% and 65%, generally consistent with balanced housing market conditions.

“The beginning of September saw a burst of new supply for buyers to choose from before things generally quiet down for the winter,” said James Mabey, CREA Chair. “While some buyers may choose to take advantage, others may be inclined to wait as the bulk of future rate cuts from the Bank of Canada are now expected to show up in a matter of months as opposed to years.”

At the end of September 2024, there were 4.1 months of inventory nationally, down from 4.2 months at the end of August. The long-term average is 5.1 months of inventory, with a seller’s market below 3.6 months and a buyer’s market above 6.5 months.

Home Prices

The National Composite MLS® Home Price Index (HPI) inched up 0.1% from August to September; however, small ups and downs aside, the bigger picture is that prices at the national level have remained mostly flat since the beginning of the year.

The non-seasonally adjusted National Composite MLS® HPI stood 3.3% below September 2023, a smaller decline than the 3.9% declines recorded in July and August. Given the price weakness seen towards the end of 2023, negative year-over-year comparisons will likely continue to shrink.

Bottom Line

Potential homebuyers remain on the sidelines awaiting further rate cuts by the Bank of Canada. As long as home prices are flat, purchasers have no compelling reason to take immediate action. This should change gradually. With new supply on the market, sales should continue to rise this month.

With weak economic activity expected in Q3 and Q4, BoC rate reductions will continue well into 2025. Given standard seasonal housing activity patterns, we will likely see strong home sales in the spring. Governor Macklem has commented that more significant rate cuts would be forthcoming if the economy weakens too aggressively and inflation falls below the 2% target. This would be welcome news for housing. We expect the overnight policy rate to fall to 2.5% before the end of next year. It is now at 4.25%–well above the current inflation rate.

The September CPI data, released this morning, showed a marked decline in headline inflation to a mere 1.6% y/y. The decline was due to the September downdraft in gasoline prices, reflecting the weakening global economy. However, core inflation measures were unchanged from August to September, and gas prices have risen so far in October owing to stepped-up Middle East tensions. Nevertheless, excluding shelter costs–including mortgage interest payments, rent and renovation costs–inflation last month was 1.8%–below the Bank of Canada’s 1%-to-3% target band. This, combined with the slowdown in GDP growth, may trigger a 50 basis point rate cut at the October 23 Governing Council meeting.

Housing activity will continue to edge upward gradually through the remainder of 2024, accelerating as we approach the seasonally strong spring housing market.

More Good News On The Canadian Inflation Front

The Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 1.6% year over year in September, the slowest pace since February 2021 and down from a 2.0% gain in August 2024. The main contributor to headline deceleration was lower year-over-year gasoline prices in September (-10.7%) compared with August (-5.1%). The all-items CPI, excluding gasoline, rose 2.2% in September, matching the increase in August for this measure.

Although the rate at which prices increase has slowed, price levels remain elevated. Compared with September 2021, the CPI rose 12.7% in September. Canadians continue to feel the impact of higher price levels for day-to-day basics such as rent (+21.0%) and food purchased from stores (+20.7%), which increased during that same 3-year period.

The CPI fell 0.4% in September after a 0.2% decline in August. Lower gasoline prices led to both the monthly and yearly movement in September. On a seasonally adjusted monthly basis, the CPI remained unchanged at 0.0%.

The central bank’s two core inflation measures remain sticky. Both measures were unchanged in September (see chart below). According to Bloomberg calculations, a three-month moving average of those measures fell to an annualized pace of 2.1% from 2.3% in August.

According to Bloomberg News, “After the release, traders in overnight swaps upped their bets that the Bank of Canada will opt for a larger rate cut at next week’s decision, putting the odds of a half-percentage-point reduction at about 75%. Previously, the odds were around 50%.” The Canadian dollar weakened further on the news relative to the greenback. The loonie has fallen for ten days, the longest streak since 2017. Canadian debt rallied across the yield curve, outperforming US Treasuries and pushing the two-year Canada benchmark yield to 3.03% and the 5-year bond yield to 2.92% by mid-day.

Tuesday’s data marks the first time since February 2021 that inflation is below the central bank’s 2% target and is the ninth straight month of headline rates running within its target range.

With inflationary pressures continuing to ebb and policymakers focusing more on preserving economic growth, the data give the central bank options to reduce rates quicker after cutting borrowing costs at 25 basis points at the past three meetings.

Bottom Line

While the September employment data were stronger than expected, Q3 GDP growth is slated to be roughly 1.8%, well below the Bank of Canada’s 2.8% forecast. Today’s inflation report is the last important data point before the Bank meets again on October 23. Late last month, BoC Governor Tiff Macklem warned that growth may be below policymakers’ previous expectations in Q3.

Excluding shelter costs, the consumer price index rose 0.4% from a year ago compared to 0.5% in August. Mortgage interest costs and rent remained the most significant contributors to the annual inflation rate change. However, rent prices increased at a slower pace in September, rising 8.2% versus 8.9% in August. Tuition fees, priced annually in September, also grew slower, increasing 1.8% compared with 2.5% last year.

Regionally, inflation is now at or below 2% in every province, with prices rising slower in September than in August in all ten provinces. The central bank will release new economic forecasts in the Monetary Policy Report next week. Macklem has said,  “decisive monetary policy action and the unblocking of supply chains” means “uncertainty about costs and inflation are much lower today than two years ago”.

Stronger-Than-Expected September Jobs Report Reduces Prospect Of Larger Rate Cuts

Statistics Canada released September employment data today, showing a marked uptick in job growth and the first decline in the unemployment rate this year. Employment rose by 46,700 in September, following four months of little change.

Despite the employment gain, the employment rate—the proportion of the population aged 15 and older who is employed—fell 0.1 percentage points to 60.7% in September. The employment rate has been on a downward trend since reaching a recent peak of 62.4% in January and February 2023, as growth in the population aged 15 and older in the Labour Force Survey (LFS) outpaced employment growth.

Also, good news: The number of private sector employees increased for the second consecutive month, rising by 61,000 (+0.5%) in September and bringing the year-over-year increase in private sector employment to 193,000 (+1.5%). Public sector employment fell by 24,000 (-0.5%) in September but was up 3.0% (+128,000) compared with 12 months earlier. Self-employment changed little in the month and on a year-over-year basis.

Full-time employment rose by 112,000 (+0.7%) in September, the most significant gain since May 2022. The increase was partially offset by a decline in part-time work (-65,000; -1.7 %).

The unemployment rate fell for the first time since January—a mere 0.1% decline, but we’ll take it, and now stands at 6.5%. This follows a rise of two ticks in August. The jobless rate is well above the 4.9% cycle low when job vacancies were rampant. Discouraged workers have dropped out of the labour force. The labour force participation rate is down 0.7 percentage points year-over-year.

Wage inflation is a big issue for the Bank of Canada, and this time, average hourly wages increased by 4.6%, down from the August rate of 5.0%.  Other measures of wage inflation are now even lower.

Bottom Line
Economists are still divided on whether the Bank of Canada will cut by 25 or 50 basis points. Next week’s inflation data, released on Tuesday, October 15, will become all the more critical. The numbers are expected to be good, meaning low. The economy slowed markedly in the third quarter, and monetary policy remains overly restrictive. Stay tuned!